Why the Dodgers’ Shocking DFA of an All-Star Pitcher Could Be a Genius Move—or a Costly Gamble

Updated: June 2024

A franchise at a crossroads: When even All-Stars aren’t safe from the roster shuffle.

The Move That Had Baseball Twitter Gasping

Picture this: You’re scrolling through your phone on a lazy Tuesday afternoon when a notification pops up—“Dodgers designate All-Star pitcher for assignment”. Your first thought? Did I read that wrong? Nope. In a league where $300 million contracts are handed out like participation trophies, the Dodgers just cut bait on a proven arm. No trade. No injury cover-up. Just… DFA’d, like a September call-up who forgot to pack his glove.

This isn’t some back-end reliever we’re talking about. This is a pitcher who’s thrown in All-Star Games, dominated lineups, and probably has a highlight reel longer than your Netflix queue. So what gives? Is this the cold, calculating genius of Andrew Friedman’s front office, or a rare misstep from baseball’s most analytical franchise? Let’s break down the why, the what’s next, and whether this could backfire spectacularly—or set the stage for another Dodgers deep October run.

Why DFA an All-Star? The Cold, Hard Math Behind the Move

1. The Salary Cap Gymnastics

Baseball doesn’t have a hard salary cap, but the luxury tax might as well be one for the Dodgers. Los Angeles is perennially flirting with (or outright shattering) the competitive balance tax threshold. Every dollar counts when you’re trying to both keep Mookie Betts in pinstripes and outbid the Mets for the next big Japanese sensation.

By DFA’ing this pitcher, the Dodgers free up a roster spot and potentially shed salary—either by trading him (with cash considerations) or letting another team pick up his contract. It’s like canceling your gym membership because you could work out at home… but you’re also eyeing that Peloton deal next month.

2. The “We’ve Got Depth” Flex

The Dodgers’ farm system is like that one friend who always has a backup plan (and a backup to the backup). While other teams are scrambling to find a fifth starter, L.A. has multiple top prospects knocking on the door, ready to prove they belong. This move signals confidence in their pipeline—or, as cynics might say, overconfidence.

“The Dodgers don’t rebuild. They reload. But even reloads can jam if the timing’s off.”

—Unnamed NL Scout, probably sipping coffee in a hotel lobby

3. The Analytics Say… “Meh”

Here’s where it gets geeky. This pitcher might have the name recognition, but the numbers? They’ve been trending in the wrong direction:

• ERA+ dipping below league average
• Fastball velocity down 1.3 mph from his peak
• Barrel rate against him? Up like a Bitcoin bull run.

In Friedman’s world, sentiment doesn’t win championships. If the data says a player’s decline is irreversible, the Dodgers will pull the trigger—even if it means swallowing a chunk of salary. It’s brutal, but it’s the game.

What This Means for the Dodgers, the Pitcher, and the Rest of MLB

For the Dodgers: High Risk, High Reward

If this move works, it’s another feather in Friedman’s cap. The Dodgers stay under the luxury tax, a young arm steps up, and they cruise to another 100-win season. If it fails? Well, imagine the memes if their rotation collapses in August while this pitcher thrives elsewhere.

Best-case scenario: They flip him to a contender for a mid-tier prospect, like turning a $20 bill into two tens.
Worst-case scenario: He signs with the Giants and dominates them in September. (Cue Dodgers fans collectively groaning.)

For the Pitcher: A Humbling Reset

Getting DFA’d as an All-Star is like being ghosted after a third date—you thought things were going well. But here’s the silver lining: He’ll clear waivers (unless a team claims him), become a free agent, and likely latch on with another squad. Possible landing spots?

• Guardians: Always need pitching, always cheap.
• Orioles: Young team that could use a veteran presence.
• Dodgers’ NL West rivals: Because baseball loves drama.

For the Rest of MLB: A Wake-Up Call

This move sends a message: No one is safe. Not even All-Stars. Not even fan favorites. If you’re underperforming, the Dodgers will find a replacement. It’s a reminder that in modern baseball, loyalty is a two-way street—and the street is paved with analytics.

DFA 101: What Does “Designated for Assignment” Actually Mean?

If you’re new to the MLB transaction wire, “DFA” might sound like a fancy accounting term. Here’s the no-BS breakdown:

Step 1: The Team “DFA’s” a Player

The club removes the player from their 40-man roster but keeps them in limbo for 7 days. During this time, the player is in baseball purgatory—still getting paid, but not active.

Step 2: The Waiver Wire Game Begins

Other teams can claim the player (and their contract) within those 7 days. Priority goes to the worst record in the same league, then the other league. If multiple teams claim him, the worst team wins the lottery.

Step 3: The Outcomes

Three possible endings:

1. Claimed: Another team picks him up (and his salary).
2. Traded: The Dodgers strike a deal before the 7 days expire.
3. Released: He becomes a free agent if no one bites.

⚡ Pro Tip:

Teams often DFA players as a strategic move to sneak them through waivers (e.g., if they have an injury or want to stash them in the minors). It’s not always a “goodbye forever.”

Is This a Smart Move? We Asked the (Hypothetical) Experts

The Case For the DFA

“The Dodgers are playing 4D chess.” —Analytics Nerd
If the pitcher’s metrics show irreversible decline, cutting ties now prevents a midseason collapse. Plus, the Dodgers’ bullpen depth is insane. They can afford to gamble.

The Case Against the DFA

“You don’t fix a leaky roof by throwing out the ladder.” —Old-School Scout
All-Stars don’t grow on trees. Even if he’s struggling, his playoff experience could be invaluable in October. And what if the prospects aren’t ready?

The Wildcard: Clubhouse Chemistry

Was this pitcher a locker-room leader? A mentor to younger arms? Sometimes, the intangibles matter more than the ERA. If his presence was glue, this move could backfire in ways the spreadsheets can’t predict.

What’s Next? 3 Dominoes to Watch

1. The Trade Deadline Fireworks

The Dodgers now have payroll flexibility and a roster spot to play with. Expect them to be aggressive at the deadline—think a rental bat or another arm. (Looking at you, [Hot Free Agent Pitcher].)

2. The Prospect Pipeline Test

Names like [Top Dodgers Prospect] and [Another Prospect] could get the call. If they falter, this DFA becomes a black mark. If they thrive? Friedman looks like a genius (again).

3. The Revenge Narrative

If this pitcher lands with a contender and dominates the Dodgers down the stretch, it’s the ultimate “I told you so” moment. Baseball loves a good revenge story.

Hungry for More Dodgers Drama?

Dive into these deep cuts:

• How the Dodgers Built Baseball’s Most Ruthless Farm System
• The Luxury Tax Explained: Why the Dodgers Keep Flirting With Penalty Hell
• 5 Times the Dodgers’ “Cold” Moves Paid Off (And 2 Times They Didn’t)

Your Turn: Genius or Blunder?

So, what’s the verdict? Is this another masterstroke by the Dodgers’ brain trust, or a rare whiff that’ll haunt them in October? Drop your take in the comments—and don’t hold back.

And if you’re craving more no-nonsense baseball breakdowns, hit subscribe. We’re just getting warmed up for trade deadline season… and trust us, it’s gonna be wild.

🔥 Hot Take? Share this with your most argumentative baseball buddy. Debate settled by first pitch.